1. “If the Brits didn’t come here, someone else woulda.”
If I didn’t bash that nerd in school someone else woulda. If I didn’t abuse that orphan homeless girl someone else woulda. If I didn’t put a sweatshop in that country someone else woulda. “Someone else woulda” doesn’t justify anything.
2. “The Brits were a more advanced society.”
They had more advanced weapons, that doesn’t make them a more advanced society. North Korea has nukes. They could blow us up tomorrow. Does that make them more advanced than us? No.
And seriously, compare how 1700s Brit society and 1700s Aboriginal society treated their citizens. Women? Kids? Disabled? The hungry? Paint the worst possible picture of both if you like, you’d be hard pressed to say Brit society looks better (and I’m not saying Aboriginal society was a utopia either).
3. “What’s the point of going on about it, it’s in the past.”
*Rafiki coconut staff to the head* The past still hurts in real tangible ways. One example, from about 1910-1970 Aboriginal people were forced, by law, to work and live where the Government put them for 16 hour days, but then in many cases the Government “withheld”/“lost” their wages. These are the Stolen Wages cases.
Now, lots of these people are still alive. They are now old and they have bugger-all money for their retirement even though they worked hard for decades. This didn’t happen to white fellas, just black ones. Why? Well, to fully explain it we have to talk about how disempowered Black people became due to invasion. This put them in such a crap position by 1910-1970, that they could be exploited like this, with the flow on effects flowing on to this day.
But if you still think there’s no point going on about tragedies from the past, let’s scrap Anzac Day.
4. “I didn’t do it, Brits 100s of years ago did, why should I feel guilty?”
I don’t feel guilty. I don’t want you to feel guilty. I just want you to stop standing in the way of accepting the truth of what happened so we can all move on. As stated above, the past still has impact today. Yes you and I personally didn’t do it. But you and I still reap great advantage from what happened then. Hell, the reason my government has so much money sloshing around is cause they still have all that “stolen wages” money - with interest! And all that money that shoulda gone to Aboriginal people when their land was first taken! And all that money that through inheritance laws is in the hands of white people when it should be in the hands of black ones! The injustices of the past are completely paid forward to create the inequalities of today. Not all inequalities! But some of them. So yep, you and I didn’t do it. But by denying this past injustice and allowing all the injustices that still flow from it to fester, you are perpetuating it. If you really want all of us to “move on” you need to acknowledge this history. We can’t “move on” till we do.
5. “It was normal at the time in that society.”
Should we cut 1940s Germans slack because “Jews are awful and Nazis are great” was normal at the time in that society? Should we cut current Saudi Arabians slack because “women are second class citizens and gays are scum” is normal at the time in that society? Nup. There were heaps of people back in the 1700s, 1940s and now that knew and shouted loudly that the Brits, Germans and Saudi Arabians respectively were doing something crap. It was normalised because someone had something to gain from normalising it. And there were people then who could see through it. “Normal at the time” doesn’t justify it.
Think about it. “I genuinely believe that black people are inferior so I am entitled to take their land,their resources, have sex with the ones I find hot whenever I like and use them for slave labour so I don’t have to do the hard work.” What a spectacularly convenient thing to “genuinely believe.”